3 min read
What to do with trophies and old awards
Trophies, plaques and medals are heavy, named, and almost unsellable. Sort them by weight and material first, pry off the engraved plates, and keep two instead of forty.
Trophies are the one thing in a house that almost nobody wants secondhand. They're heavy, they have somebody's name on them, and the shelf they sit on is usually in a room you've been avoiding. The good news is that the job is small once you know what to look for.
Feel the weight before you look at it
Most trophies are resin or plastic molded to look like marble and bronze. Pick one up: if it's light for its size, it's plastic all the way through and it's trash. The heavy ones usually have a real cast metal figure or base, and that's where the only salvage value is. A magnet tells you almost nothing here — brass and bronze don't stick either.
Sort into three piles on the floor: light plastic, heavy metal, and anything with a hallmark or maker's mark stamped on the bottom. The third pile is small and it's the only one you should slow down for.
The engraved plate is the part worth prying off
The brass or nickel plate screwed to the front is often the densest metal on the whole thing, and scrap yards buy brass by weight. A small screwdriver gets most plates off in seconds. Keep them in a coffee can until you have a few pounds, then call the yard and ask what their minimum is before you drive over — plenty won't bother with a coffee can.
Pewter and bronze figures are worth more than the plate. If a figure or a bowl is stamped pewter, bronze or sterling on the bottom, it belongs with your metal and silver sorting, not with the trophies.
What to check on each one
- Lift it — light plastic goes in the bag, heavy goes in the metal pile
- Look at the bottom for a stamped word: pewter, bronze, brass, sterling
- Check medals for a tiny stamp on the rim or the loop
- Keep the ribbon only if the medal itself is worth keeping
- Set aside military medals and anything with a unit or ship name — those go with the paperwork
Take one photo of the whole shelf
You don't need forty trophies to remember a season. Take a picture of the shelf before you take it apart, then keep one or two you'd actually put out. The rest of the memory lives in the photo, and the photo doesn't need dusting.
If a parent is still alive and proud of that shelf, don't do this in front of them. Box three and put them where they can see them. The rest can leave quietly.
Call before you load the trunk
A few places do take trophies for reuse — a workshop that re-engraves the plates, a school theater department, a program that hands medals to kids. The catch is volume. Most will take a dozen and not a hundred, and they want them clean. Call, describe what you've got in one sentence, and ask whether they want the bases too.
Thrift stores are the opposite. Most won't put a named trophy on a shelf, so don't fill a donation box with them and call it done.
What the trash actually takes
Trophies are mixed material, so the recycling bin is the wrong place — a resin figure glued to a stone base is exactly what a sorting line rejects. Bag them and put them in the trash, and wrap any broken ones. If your hauler has a weight limit or a bulky-item rule, one can full of trophies can be heavy enough to matter.
A whole shelving unit's worth is a conversation with your hauler or a trip to the transfer station, not twelve weeks of sneaking them into the bin.
The thing people get wrong is starting with the valuable-looking ones. The heavy figure, the medal, the engraved plate — that's three minutes of work. The other ninety trophies are the actual job, and they only go fast if you decide by weight and stop reading the nameplates.
Keep going
- Where to start when there is too much stuff
A house full of possessions is not one job, it is a few hundred small decisions. This is the order that keeps you from making them twice.
- Clearing an estate: the first few days
What to do before anything is sold, donated or thrown out, and why the order matters more than the speed.
- Sorting a storage unit without paying for it twice
A storage unit is a monthly bill attached to a pile of decisions you have not made yet. Here is how to empty one deliberately.